Hooray for the Urban Living Index: A new evidence base to help urban planners & policy makers

Wednesday, December 23, 2015

The co-authors of the newly developed Urban Living Index – The Urban Taskforce and McCrindle Research – rightly state that the challenge in planning for Sydney’s future is to ensure that population growth does not compromise its “world-beating lifestyle”. By tracking five key categories that produce a measure of liveability in a city, the Index is a great first step in developing an evidence base to monitoring changes as the Sydney metropolitan area as it grows – both outwards and upwards.

A key theme in most media reporting about the Index is that upwards growth – through increased residential density – is the way to ensure high levels of amenity and accessibility are maintained as Sydney grows, and that a reliance on outwards expansion may compromise such liveability standards. Although the Index broadly shows that denser residential areas rate highly from a liveability perspective, we need to dig a bit deeper to understand what it is about these areas that make them liveable. It is not just a case of these highly rated areas being dense, which is actually just a relative measure of compactness. There are many more factors at play than compactness in making a place liveable and sustainable.

The structure of the overall city, with its public transport and road network and its layout of employment and retail locations, influences transport choice more than most other factors. At the local level, good walking and cycling connectivity to local shopping and public transport services is the key to how we move around. Of course, there is also the influence that individual behaviours, intentions and beliefs have on how a community might inhabit and use places and spaces. Density also plays a role, especially population density, as this helps underpin social and economic sustainability in local areas. But density is not the end game – far from it.

For example, the Index shows that Marrickville has a relatively low high density component for an inner city area (40%) but a very high liveability ranking. On the other hand, Woollahra has a higher high density component (50%) but a relatively low liveability ranking for an inner urban area. If one interrogates the rankings, you’ll see that Marrickville ranks highest for accessibility (which considers the factors I mention above), whereas Woollahra has a relatively low ranking for accessibility. This example, and there are many others across the metropolitan region, shows that higher density areas do not necessarily guarantee higher levels of accessibility.

The upshot of policy makers and planners thinking that increased density inevitably produces more liveable and sustainable urban areas has resulted in, until recently, a saturation of multi-level apartment construction in infill areas. And some of these areas have been bereft of the factors that the Index shows achieves high levels of amenity: within walking distance to rail or priority light rail and bus routes that connect to employment locations; within walking distance to a plentiful supply of local shops and services; well-connected and safe walking and cycling routes; and a range of different residential options that help create a vibrant social mix of different family types.

I think the Index helpfully shows that density is just part of the story. The Index is comprised of twenty separate measures- and many of these are not at all reliant on densification. As I’ve shown above, we cannot simply assume that areas of high density automatically generate liveable and sustainable outcomes. There are simply too many factors at play to make this conclusion.

Dr Michael Grosvenor, Principal MGC

Welcome to our blog...

We have a passion for research that tells a story, that can be presented visually, that brings about change and improves organisations. And we hope these resources help you know the times.

Our Social Media Sites

Facebook | McCrindle Research Social Media YouTube | McCrindle Research Social Media Twitter | McCrindle Research Social Media Flickr | McCrindle Research Social Media Pinterest | McCrindle Research Social Media Google Plus | McCrindle Research Social Media LinkedIn | McCrindle Research Social Media Mark McCrindle Slideshare

Last 150 Articles


long weekend entertainment proactive urban living travel 10 years healthy future urban taskforce stay home forecast in the media divorce rate System's Architect year 12 housing work mates Hornsby Shire Council HSC urban living index house price Financial Planning Week public speaking millenials renting investor living victoria staff daily commute Wagga Wagga perth students future of education SMART manly WA names debate tea future Charlotte Kiwi leadership workshop Adelaide middle class Skilling skills meals James Ward Aussies conference presentation Tasmania growing population shifts society trends australians staying home more TDE gender baby names report buildings housing trends potts point PSI baby boom litter work award media release collaborative learn Christmas lunch know the times bus rise of local World Water Day divorce mother's day follow dreaming thought leadership new york times social trends Hills Shire Council young australians poker master emerging generations rent transport blaxland optus forum outsourcing population wedding 2020 train rule keeper TAS wage the average aussie grave decision Myth repayments population growth future proofing ashley fell hornsby summer local communities keynote population map families motivate politics sustainable paying to work high density living population milestone events conference celebration relational aged care norwest clothing Mark McCrindle Financial Planning Association of Australia christianity weekly earnings online salary increasing densification Deaths royal baby authenticity aged care puzzle office South Australia DIY innovation suburban living world youth day renter of the future village Research Executive internet commuters Australian Families rich business sydney hills contiki language the australian dream rental stress offenders Word Up employment house prices parents cloudy days identity The ABC of XYZ New Zealand ACF 2016 equip analysis domestic social issues ipswich financial independence capital cities overcast trends of 2017 home ownership Australian schools father's day plans Australian Trends sentiments children school satisfaction tips townhouses baby names NEETs SA jobs bondi infographic baby name predictions "know the times" breakfast global financial crisis mccrindle cold fresh brand experience 1975 couple changing face of sydney tableau food CBD earn professional development social life Canberra anzac group demographic demographics cultural diversity trends millennials program royal Andrew Duffin national private wealth friends Northern Beaches Christian School marriages sun office space baby boomers social commentator research visualisation holiday eliane miles financial small business marrickville challenge media visual house facts media activity optus my business awards workshop Education Future Forum Assistant Store Manager mythbusters data visualisation Res Vis ease of travel future proof ageing 2012 mover and shaker baby brand earnings menai gold coast seasons January 26th statistics video brisbane housing market social enquiry high density church sydneycity unaffordable social media career dream sports Crime Rates life recap Wellington poor affordability education research ACT Melbourne JOMO FPA global pharmacies economy logan SMSF professional Australian Population quote hello fresh trades GPO year 7 ABS high school holidays greatness dessert rising house prices mobile sector wide study geomapping case study housing growth finance women states mccrindle tea environmental scanning deloitte community event young people employers engagement wellbeing research 23 million Northern beaches Event presentation daily telegraph not for profit household newspaper rain emerging trends Population Clock Channel Seven Generation Y workplace culture learning styles trend REIV Conference bureau financial fears family narcissism visualisation in depth interviews home owner list award winner click workforce digital grandparents average aussie investing research data ferry darwin prince george google for education Valentine’s Day dare to dream 2015 mortgage presentations wealth and income distribution resilience NBRS fears Australian Dream Christmas presents 2017 men social lives happiness 1994 meetings community lifestyle tattoos research report suburb Aussie tertiary education christian student trend tuesday culturally diverse hills shire brands 2016 social researchers leadership optimistic product slideshare sydney speaker Merry Christmas faith spend eliane 40 million Christchurch growth moreton bay property price research pack learner educated demographic trends teach community engagement area princess charlotte not-for-profit social winter blues entrepreneurial goal education future the hills Bathburst society social shifts home sydneysiders sector wide cancelling plans woolworths Australians weather work-life Northern Beaches car hobart research services consumer lalor park 1968 neutral bay thrive marriage engage qualitative research networking insight public holiday budget snapshot households suburbs Gen Y faux-cilising Christmas season interactive criminal Scouts communications 2013 NT retirement DESTEL VET participants speakers low density Macquarie University crime city Channel 7 tv the hills shire staying in conference speaker crows nest New South Wales marketing collaboration Australian Home wolloomooloo unemployment study Social Trend publication English February 16 VIC moderators guide organisations 2014 intern Sydney Hills Business Chamber generation alpha world census 2016 socialising NBRS Architecture Australian demographics data generations panel generation Australian Communities Trends going out change mccrindle research child care land of the middle class future of work Real Estate Institute of Victoria national crime rates debt Australian Census online shopping cost of living social commentary The Daily Edition christmas youth news easy rider charity sector learning Royals communication FOMO Australian communities millionth Love researcher stats nfp religion national wealth Engineering Manager spirituality REIV National Conference acf15 Vocational education safe property real mining boom ashley mckenzie focus group responsive kate middleton Duchess of Cambridge royal family high density apartments wealth royal influence financial future Tuesday Trends census builders global generations australia results educhat shopping omnibus Western Australia schools students Sydney pharmacy teaching aussie culture vegemite apartment social impact generational trends alpha culture story organisational culture belief Work place professional speaker Do It Yourself annual income Queensland: QLD owning a home Tuesday Trend Netflix environment the changing face of mythbusting communicate cancelling event professional services medicine training personal growth school students curiosity Australian Bureau of Statistics ethnography typical australian income demographer personalities media commentary sydney event technology huffington post sunburnt country affordable entrepreneur infographic wall 2016 census results vegetarian market research New Zeland resource 2016 census internships focus groups Northern Territory cancel plans communities capital city balance wages monarchy trends of 2016 sydney metro Births waverton innovative 1980 coffee trends analyst customer Kirsten Brewer shopper's pick etiquette government Caregiver travelling careers #censusfail demographic transformations google ideas supply and demand wealth and income state internship Generation X 24,000,000 survey residents teachers define pyrmont australian social research cars futurist non profit university survey design wealth distribution Australia Day 24 million emerging technologies youth unemployment social analysis cash megatrends business index workplace forecasting Financial Planning Association social change mentor volunteers mccrindle in the media australian communities trends report new office shbc socialites generation Z mateship graphs gen alpha housing affordability earning storytelling hopes teleworking tuesday VET sector keynote speaker conferences leader investment economic faux-cilise relevant experience NSW jobs of the future census fail Australia Day 2017 schools toys Real Estate social research education sector post rationalism education water report faux-ciliser sunny days Queensland cost baby name trends friendship ultimo public speaker office opening baby name Wodonga census results event baby names australia report data analyst australian communities forum education future report parenting Sydney keynote speaker priorities ageing population local Geoff Brailey commute Territory insights school financial dreams cooking twentyseventeen winter property market energy IT Specialists urban future-proof teacher selfie entrepreneurs of today university degree McCrindle Speakers EFF consumerism easter goals Gen X cartodb social researcher business performance ACF house price rise gen z group session